Why I Disagree with Multiple Work Email Addresses

Smart people will disagree – often and with gusto.


I have read at least three articles recently where productivity specialists are recommending to readers to create and manage multiple emails for work.


The reasons include:

  • Giving VIPs access to a special email address to which you pay greater attention
  • Branding different businesses
  • To reduce email overwhelm


I respectfully disagree with this approach.  Having multiple email addresses generally results in multiple email accounts to manage as well as multiple headaches.


Now, I’m not on an island here.  Other productivity gurus preach consolidation of email as well.


Why?  Because managing multiple email addresses is incredibly hard!  Dividing a stack of paper into two or more piles doesn’t decrease the amount of paper, it just gives you more piles to sort through.



Here are three multi-address scenarios I’ve regularly seen with clients and the advice I’ve given.



Scenario One:  My work email changed, and I’m afraid to shut down the old address


Companies change names.  People leave their ISPs.  Email addresses go bye-bye.  This is life.


Trying to manage your old account as well as your new one for an extended period of time is unproductive and confusing to those with whom you correspond.


My advice:  Send out a notification to key contacts that your email address is changing.  Check the old account once a day for no more than 30 days.  Create an autoreply in the old account that gives your new contact info.


After a reasonable time period (maybe 90 days?), shut the old email address down completely.



Scenario Two:  My primary email became overwhelming so I created another one


First, recall the statement above about what happens when you divide a stack of paper into two piles.  The perceived decrease in the volume of paper is an optical illusion.


Secondly, by creating other email addresses, you have increased the administrative burden on those with whom you correspond.  They now have to think “Which address should I use?” before composing a message.


My advice:  Practice good email management in your one, and only one, business email inbox.  It can be done, I promise.



Scenario Three:  I run different businesses


You may have many different domains that correspond with your various brands.


My advice:  If you are effectively managing the various inboxes, rock on.  If you find it difficult to be as attentive and responsive as you need to be, first make sure that all mailboxes are coming to the same place.  Both Gmail and Outlook can handle multiple accounts in the same place.


Secondly, consider whether you could designate a single account from which all of your replies would come.  To do this, you would need to set up automatic forwarding from all accounts into this single account.  You would have one, and only one, work inbox to manage.



So, only one account, really?


Please note that all the scenarios above refer to multiple work email accounts.  I am a proponent of having a separate personal email account.


Work situations change from time to time, and your company owns your work account.  There is no expectation of privacy with work email.  So, I think it is important to have your own personal email account.



And, what about all the SPAM I get?


If you are overwhelmed by the mailing lists and automated notifications you receive, you may want to create a “throwaway” email account.


Here’s the critical distinction with this address…you rarely if ever access it and certainly don’t worry about managing it well.


If you want to read the free whitepaper first before giving a company your real email (sorry Hubspot!), you can use the throwaway address.  Want the 20% off coupon, use the throwaway account.


Additionally, if you are doing some online shopping and don’t care whether you see the shipping notifications, use the throwaway address during checkout.  You’ll receive a lot less spam in your primary email account.





Just like you wouldn’t mount a second mailbox at the end of your driveway to accommodate all your postal mail, don’t create additional work email addresses in an effort to increase efficiency.


Your email problem will still exist, it will just have more places in which to hide.


Conquer Your Email Today eBook

Are you tired of letting email run (ruin?) your day?

Read my eBook Conquer Your Email Today…because there is no tomorrow.

Dr. Melissa GratiasMelissa Gratias (pronounced “Gracious”) used to think that productivity was a result of working long hours. And, she worked a lot of hours. Then, she learned that productivity is a skill set, not a personality trait. Now, Melissa is a productivity expert who coaches and trains other businesspeople to be more focused, balanced, and effective. She is a prolific writer and speaker who travels the world helping people change how they work and improve how they live. Contact her at getproductive@melissagratias.com or 912-417-2505. Sign up to receive her productivity tips via email.



  1. Julie Bestry

    Great advice, as always. Having two accounts at which spammers can find you just leaves you with twice the spam!

    I have the ability to have multiple addresses at my domain, but as long as I’m the only one looking at email, it didn’t make logical sense to separate the company account from the “me” account. And yes, I have all my email from any accounts (grrr, I’m looking at you, Gmail) feed into my one inbox. Nobody should ever have to go in search of email or have to maintain multiple boxes. The world of email should bow down before your royal wisdom!

  2. Linda Samuels

    I am with you 100% on this one, Melissa! I wouldn’t say I like having multiple email accounts, and most of my email is managed from one address. However, I had to set up some alternate email addresses due to some technical requirements, but those are not given out or regularly used. I prefer going to one place to process everything. For me, it’s a time saver.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Like what you read?

Get new posts directly in your inbox!

You might also like these posts…

Enjoying these posts? Make sure you dont miss any!

If you enjoy my blog posts and want to make sure you never miss one - sign up for my newsletter! When you do, you'll also get instant access to my FREE webinar on interruptions in the workplace.

Interruptions can kill productivity. With one “Got a minute?” from a coworker or one stray thought swirling in your brain, the flow of your work can be completely disrupted.

The trouble is that few people have concrete strategies to get back on task quickly after an interruption. Some people completely lose focus…for hours! If you have tried reducing interruptions, but they still impact your ability to be effective at work, this free webinar is for you.